DD broke the "pearl" off of my oyster orni, but the orni is fine. I dropped one of my Possible Dreams Santas and one leg shattered into a few pieces. I mananged to superglue him together enough that you have to really look from the front to see it (don't be staring at his backside or you'll see under the coat that he's missing part of his upper leg)! DD dropped a star ornament too ("Mommy, I'm sorry to break Jesus' star...")
There are only a few ornies that would really bother me to lose and I put those on top so DD can't get to them.