call tony
***Official American Idol Thread***
- Thread starter Jeff Westover
- Start date
- Watchers 12
call tony
AI In a Nutshell -- Top Four
David Cook -- Hungry like a Wolf? What that...? Of all the billions of songs he could choose why this one? I think he got it right, I was expecting much more from him tonight. Second song rocked and it's enough to keep him around.
Syesha Mercado -- She wouldn't be so bad if she didn't talk. As it was, her Tina Turner was nothing special to me. Her second was better but the melt-down at what Randy was saying was over the top. He was right, she butchered a classic.
Jar-Jar Castro -- Epic disaster. He's been mailing it in since he made the top ten. His Bob Marley was simply horrific. But leave it to him to blow the LYRICS on a Dylan song...nobody could understand Dylan when he sang so how could he possibly mess it up. He single-handedly has made David Archuleta the top dog because....
David Archuleta -- ...now gets ALL the teeny votes to himself after Jar-Jar melted down. Little David was completely true to his audience with his song choices -- both brilliant -- and while he'll garner very few legit votes from the 25-50 crowd he's got everyone else sewn up.
Jar-Jar HAS GOT to go tomorrow.
David Cook -- Hungry like a Wolf? What that...? Of all the billions of songs he could choose why this one? I think he got it right, I was expecting much more from him tonight. Second song rocked and it's enough to keep him around.
Syesha Mercado -- She wouldn't be so bad if she didn't talk. As it was, her Tina Turner was nothing special to me. Her second was better but the melt-down at what Randy was saying was over the top. He was right, she butchered a classic.
Jar-Jar Castro -- Epic disaster. He's been mailing it in since he made the top ten. His Bob Marley was simply horrific. But leave it to him to blow the LYRICS on a Dylan song...nobody could understand Dylan when he sang so how could he possibly mess it up. He single-handedly has made David Archuleta the top dog because....
David Archuleta -- ...now gets ALL the teeny votes to himself after Jar-Jar melted down. Little David was completely true to his audience with his song choices -- both brilliant -- and while he'll garner very few legit votes from the 25-50 crowd he's got everyone else sewn up.
Jar-Jar HAS GOT to go tomorrow.
M
mammaduke
Guest
I think the two Davids will be staying this week, but will have to wait & see, You never know what America will do.
my personal opinion regarding archuleta is that it TOTALLY creeped me out seeing that little boy singing LOVE ME TENDER,
and bad as jason was, (and yes, i admit he was a tad on the sucky side
) (tho who can blame him all things considered.......) i would still rather syesha hit the bricks tonight. i honestly dont think i can stand another night of her waterworks and melodrama.
xox
and bad as jason was, (and yes, i admit he was a tad on the sucky side
) (tho who can blame him all things considered.......) i would still rather syesha hit the bricks tonight. i honestly dont think i can stand another night of her waterworks and melodrama.xox
Christmas Activities
Sponsors
