The Story of Black Peter

By Mac Carey

Before elves and eight tiny reindeer, St. Nicholas had a much more menacing assistant. Named Black Peter, this companion was the physical opposite of St. Nicholas. Tall and gaunt with a dark beard and hair, Black Peter was associated with the punitive side of Christmas. Traditionally St. Nicholas would hand out presents to good children, while it fell to Black Peter to dole out coal (and sometimes knocks on the head) to children who misbehaved.

Black Peter, or Zwarte Piet in Dutch, began in Holland in the 15th century. His dark appearance is supposed to suggest a Spaniard, a reflection of Spain’s occupation of the Netherlands at the time. Black Peter was also associated with pirates, a common threat to naughty Dutch children was that he would take them to a pirate’s hide out and beat them. He was often represented holding a large stick for this purpose. The large bag that he held was rumored to be used for stuffing children in for the trip back to Spain. At the time “Black Peter” was a euphemism for the devil, and it was thought that St. Nicholas, being a representative of God, had beaten the devil and made him his servant. Thus it fell to Black Peter to hand out the punishments, while St. Nicholas dealt with the more pleasant sides of Christmas.

While the Dutch St. Nicholas has always been represented in much the same way, similar to the original saint in long robes with a staff, tall mitre hat, and white beard, Black Peter has been depicted in many different ways. Originally a stereotypical Spaniard in pirate garb, due to the political situation in Holland at the time, his later incarnations would also reflect popular politics. In the nineteenth century, at the height of imperialism, he was alternately portrayed as an Indian and an African in traditional dress. Rather than the devil that had been made a servant of St. Nicholas, Black Peter was now thought to be a slave who had become the willing servant of St. Nicholas. Many of the illustrations took on racist symbolism, often showing Black Peter in shackles and tattered garments. Peter’s job was to remove the hay and carrots from the shoes that had been left by children underneath their chimneys, and to drop candy and gifts in their place. If the children had been bad, Peter wouldn’t remove the hay and would leave a rod in place of a gift.

In parts of central Europe like Austria, Germany, and Switzerland, the character of Black Peter was a more like a monster, with horns, long hair, and a red tongue. He was known by a variety of names: Klaubauf, Krampus, Grampus, Bartel. St. Nicholas sent naughty children to him to be beaten.

Nowadays there is still not one universal image of Black Peter, but he has lost his large stick and is usually dressed in a Renaissance page style costume with short pants, stockings, and a cap with a large feather. He has not lost his connection to Africa; he is still always portrayed by a person in blackface, and often wears gold earrings.

The character gained popularity in the twentieth century and St. Nicholas’s and Black Peter’s annual arrival in Holland became more elaborate. During World War II, it was thought that the tradition would be suspended, until Canadian soldiers offered some of their tanks to use for the purpose. It didn’t seem to make sense to have more than one St. Nicholas. So on one of the tanks rode St. Nicholas and one Black Peter, while multiple Black Peters rode on the other tanks. The tanks, with Canadian soldiers at the helm and Black Peter sitting on the back, traversed the countryside, handing out candy and gifts to children who waited by the roadside. The practice of more than one Black Peter stuck and has continued since then.

Today the negative associations have left Black Peter and he has become more of an elf-like figure, an assistant to an overloaded St. Nicholas who helps to hand out gifts every December 5th, St. Nicholas Day in Holland. The Dutch continue to stage elaborate arrivals of Santa Claus and Black Peter. In the weeks before the feast, Santa and Black Peter arrive by boat, supposedly from Spain, and are greeted by ever increasing crowds of excited children and adults.

6 thoughts on “The Story of Black Peter

  • Pingback: Black Pete Controversy Now Extends to Seattle | Defend Christmas

  • December 7, 2018 at 5:22 pm
    Permalink

    I am 75 years old and have nerd of black peter. I have always been big on celebrating st Nickss for your three boys and their children. I am shocked to hear this tale.

    Reply
  • December 10, 2019 at 9:42 pm
    Permalink

    Still doing Black face and red lips!! Shameful! And why is “Black Peter” depicted as evil?? Why couldn’t he be good. Who would willing be an evil slave?? Why couldn’t it be more Santa Claus ’. No it wouldn’t had made since to have more Black Peters either! So what you are saying is that Santa Claus had a bunch of black slaves , all named Peter doing his dirty work, so that he can keep a clean image??!! No wonder people are frightened of Black people. They have been taught since childhood, that black people are evil, which is still going on over there! Shameful!

    Reply
  • December 19, 2019 at 6:03 am
    Permalink

    Hold on a minute! This is completely wrong. It infuriates me that wrong information is given about countries traditions!!! And causing people to react without checking the facts! I am Dutch so here is the correct story: Sinterklaas is a bishop from Spain, but originally from Turkey. Zwarte Piet is originally a Moor. He HELPS Sinterklaas. He is black because of the soot from the chimney! He goes through the chimney to deliver the presents to the children on 5th December. This has been a tradition in The Netherlands for hundreds of years. And now suddenly somebody wants to associate this with slavery? Honestly, this is just making me mad. Check your facts people!

    Reply
  • December 21, 2019 at 10:53 am
    Permalink

    It never ceases to amaze me the ignorance of people. The fact that the opposite side of St Nick is dark is not racist. The opposite of light is dark, and that is all this is portraying. My wife is from Indonesia, with her father being raised in a Dutch boarding school. He explained the whole idea of how this works and why the character of the Pete is dark. And for the record, my wife is East Indian and with a dark complexion. Her dad is dark and certainly not a bigot. Stop insisting anything or anyone whom is portraying a dark or black character is racism. That is just ignorant and foolish.

    Reply
  • January 4, 2020 at 1:24 pm
    Permalink

    My mother in law is 73 years old and this was her family’s tradition as a child. She is 1 of 7 children. Thought St. Peter went by a different name in their tradition. When she was a kid, there was someone who acted as St. Peter who stood outside their house and called each kid by name to come out 1 by 1. If they were brave enough and good, they would get a stocking with fruit and candy. If they were bad, a smack on the butt ( get their stocking later.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: